Micah Lussier and Paul Peden's confusing Instagram exchange is making us wonder if they're getting back together
'I'll always be so thankful that you came into my life,' Micah Lussier wrote to ex Paul Peden

It appears Micah Lussier is getting soft.
The Love Is Blind season 4 cast member earned the title of mean girl alongside Irina Solomonova, and she left the altar in tears when her fiancé, Paul Peden, decided not to move forward with their nuptials.
Despite her fire-engine red dress at the Love Is Blind season 4 reunion, Micah remained relatively quiet and out of the spotlight, likely due to the backlash she anticipated she'd receive. But when it was revealed during the catch-up that Paul didn't think Micah would make a good mother, you could see the heartbreak in her eyes.
Though her season was tumultuous for a number of reasons, Micah is now taking a nostalgic approach to her time on TV, and it's definitely not what we were expecting.
What does Micah Lussier's confusing Instagram post *really* mean?
On Tuesday, April 25, Micah decided to send an intimate message to Paul, by way of Instagram, claiming how special their time together had been.
"Paul, I'll always be so thankful that you came into my life. We shared something so special together & no one will ever be able to replace that. No matter what I'll always love you," part of the message read.
The comments section was filled with confusion—"If he’s not posting you sis, why are you posting him," one user wrote—and, yes, support and pleas to get back together. Even Paul chimed in with a comment: "My love for you isn't going anywhere. Maybe we're together, maybe we're not, but regardless, we'll still have that no matter what."
"Maybe we're together, maybe we're not"?!
This seems a bit odd, considering a week earlier, Micah had appeared on The Viall Files podcast claiming she had thought her ex had moved on too quickly after their split. (More Paul dating rumors emerged when he pursued a connection with Wendi Kong from the pods, which ultimately did not last long.) Paul retorted with a comment to TMZ, stating that Micah "f---s off to Europe with some random person."
A post shared by micah lussier (@micah.lussier)
A photo posted by on
We're not really sure how, or why, this change of heart came to be, but a factor could be Micah's close connection with Paul's mother, Elizabeth. Not only were the two Doppelgängers, but they shared a similar bubbly personality. Micah said in an Instagram Q&A that they remain in touch: "She has been an amazing support system for me. Even though we aren't family, we will always be friends, and luckily for her and I, Paul supports that!"
Perhaps this post is a way to slowly introduce Micah's following to the idea of dating Paul once again. Are they giving things a third shot?! We'll have to turn to the 'gram for further updates on Paul and Micah. Stay tuned!
Next up? The Ultimatum: Queer Love. Catch the debut on Netflix on Wednesday, May 24.
Danielle is a writer for woman&home and My Imperfect Life, covering all-things news, lifestyle and entertainment.
The heart of her time at Future has been devoted to My Imperfect Life, where she's been attuned to the cosmos, new TV shows and relationship trends.
Before her time at Future, Danielle was the editor of Time Out New York Kids and a news editor at Elite Daily. Her work has also appeared in Domino, Chowhound, amNewYork and Newsday, among other outlets.
When Danielle is not working, you can usually find her reading a book, coffee at hand, or attempting a new recipe. (Recommendations always welcome!)
-
-
'Superbloom' relationships will inspire you to kick your situationship to the curb
Bring on the commitment—'superbloom' relationships are on the rise this summer
By Danielle Valente • Published
-
Kendall Jenner's sheer dress and flower pasties look is all we want to wear this summer—here's how to copy the fit
Kendall Jenner just made flower pasties the must-have accessory for summer 2023...
By Naomi Jamieson • Published
-
Rumor has it Lauren Speed and Cameron Hamilton are our new 'Love Is Blind' hosts, but is it true?
Fans are overwhelmingly in favor of replacing current hosts Nick and Vanessa Lachey
By Danielle Valente • Published
-
'Love Is Blind' divorces: which couples have split after tying the knot on TV?
We know about the weddings but what about the 'Love Is Blind' divorces? One season in particular ends with heartbreak
By Danielle Valente • Published
-
Revelations from the Truth or Drink 'Love Is Blind' game that we can't get over
Let's raise a (golden) wine glass to our season 4 newlyweds and their willingness to answer embarrassing questions
By Danielle Valente • Published
-
Wait, who is Jimmy Forde from 'Love Is Blind' season 4 and did he get married?
Meet Jimmy Forde, 'Love Is Blind's other hopeful romantic from the pods
By Danielle Valente • Published
-
Is Paul from 'Love Is Blind' dating Amber, his other connection from the pods?
What do we have here, Paul? 'Love Is Blind' dating drama? Do tell!
By Danielle Valente • Published
-
'Love is Blind' reunion recap: here's everything that happened
Yes, the 'Love is Blind' reunion was *sort of* live this year! Here's what went down....
By Danielle Valente • Published
-
Why is the 'Love is Blind' reunion not working and how can you watch it?
Well, Netflix really fumbled the bag this time with the live reunion...
By Mariana Cerqueira • Published
-
Are there any 'Love Is Blind' rules about wearing wedding rings? Ask Micah Lussier
An eagle-eyed TikToker seems to think Micah is telling us something with her accessories...
By Danielle Valente • Published